James Thomas MATHERS + Emily May TROTTER

No children
18561941
Birth: December 3, 1856 28 32Dumaresq Island, New South Wales, Australia
Death: August 30, 1941Taree, New South Wales, Australia
18281911
Birth: about 1828Leicestershire, England, United Kingdom
Death: May 20, 1911Taree, New South Wales, Australia
18781957
Birth: December 1, 1878 44 45Manning River District (Taree), New South Wales, Australia
Death: May 21, 1957Taree, New South Wales, Australia
Male Pioneer
18341926
Birth: about 1834 39 33Wrexham, Denbighshire, Wales, United Kingdom
Death: July 2, 1926Port Macquarie, New South Wales, Australia
18331888
Birth: October 10, 1833Maitland, New South Wales, Australia
Death: November 24, 1888Port Macquarie, New South Wales, Australia

Facts and events

Marriage about 1927
Citation details: 13899/1927 MATHERS JOHN T TROTTER EMILY M DUNGOG
Citation details: 786, 985, 1070 and 1071
Note: With the NSW Marriage Index entry showing Emily married John T Mathers and the fact that James was 7…

With the NSW Marriage Index entry showing Emily married John T Mathers and the fact that James was 71 years old at the time, raises doubts as to the validity of the numerous reverences to this marriage in the Pre 1860 Pioneer Register and the reference in the Australian Cemeteries Index web site. If anyone has the certificate of the marriage referenced, I would be pleased to receive a copy. Or can anyone provide other supporting evidence? Did she really marry James or did she marry John?